Wednesday, January 14, 2009

Annoyed with the state of US healthcare

Now that I'm pregnant, I'm really determined more than ever to birth at home. It's something I'm passionate about, and I really feel strongly that normal, low-risk women should birth in less medicalized locales where they will not be subject to routine interventions that are detrimental to their health and the health of their baby (think continuous fetal monitoring, epidurals, pitocin). I've read a lot about how our system of childbirth is far less superior than those in Europe and other Western countries, and our maternal mortality and infant mortality are much higher they should be. The higher rate has been empirically attributed to the routine use of pitocin, elective cesareans, and the lack of support to laboring mothers. When women are tethered to a bed because of an EFM they are not free to move around and thus their labor will slow down. Labor is an active, dynamic process and a woman's body KNOWS what to do, yet we rely solely on the doctor's orders which are often not consistent with research but rather with fear of litigation. So I REALLY WANT TO HAVE A HOMEBIRTH! But alas, it appears that may be out of reach. You see. Our insurance won't cover CPMs (certified professional midwife)and CNM (certified nurse midwives) are prohibited from attending homebirths in Utah per their licensing. If I want a homebirth, I have to pay out of pocket. Ok, so paying out of pocket would be comparable to paying the 20% after insurance of a hospital birth. Another problem: my insurance won't cover maternity care unless you had continuous coverage from the time of conception. We did not. Insurance coverage started January 6th. Conception was December 24th-ish, so I'm thinking that I won't be covered. So we are considering using Medicaid which would obviously put our costs considerably lower than paying for the homebirth. Medicaid also will not cover CPMs or homebirth. But, I have ethical qualms about using Medicaid. Namely that maybe it wasn't meant for college students who accidentally got pregnant but rather for actual poor people (which I guess we can be considered... because we are). But, we will still probably go on it in case we have a preemie or something like my sister had, as to avoid $20,000 in medical bills that insurance won't cover (if our insurance will even cover my maternity care). Can you lie about date of conception? I can just say my last period was mid-December. That would put conception in January. Is THAT ethical??

Maybe I'll just get prenatal care from a CNM then just have an unassisted homebirth. I've watched videos. I could probably do it. Or maybe we can fundraise for a homebirth. Or maybe I will just capitulate and go to a hospital where I don't want to be. Maybe I'll labor at home and just go to the hospital to push it out. There are some nice hospitals around. Orem Community has nurse-midwives and American Fork does waterbirths. It's looking tempting...


And this whole conundrum is related to the much bigger problem: why can't women just trust their bodies? Another bigger problem to address at a later time: patriarchy.

12 comments:

  1. Medicaid is a good option to consider...you don`t have to pay anything, and your baby is guaranteed health insurance for a year. The hard part is qualifying, but that is supposed to be easier for pregnant women, and they do not deny you because you didn`t have it until after you got pregnant. look into it, it`s a big help with the financial cost of having a baby. we didn`t have to pay a dime.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Okay I will have to email you instead of leaving a long post. Yes, also, watch the Business of Being Born on Netflix for free. My friend Bridget ( who is going to school or her CNM) and I are all about naturopathic care and we have been through the hospital birth experience. She had her second child at home, with a midwife that came to her and brought the inflatable tub. Her husband used to work for Andaluz Birthing Center. We must bring the power of birth and natural care back to the hands of the mothers and fathers.

    So, it is messed up that women and childbirth is looked at through a hospital view, even more so, a "pre-existing condition." You would probably qualify for Utah Health Plan. I had Cara on OHP and we didn't see a bill, not one at all. It was a huge blessing for us as poor working students. I am looking into a birthing center for my next one although I wish I could have my next one at home, health allowing.

    We should talk.

    ReplyDelete
  3. "Maybe I'll just get prenatal care from a CNM then just have an unassisted homebirth. I've watched videos. I could probably do it".

    Bad idea. Another bad idea is calling Patriarchy a "problem" if you value having a Priesthood leader in your home.

    ReplyDelete
  4. And by the way, since I'm from Europe, I can tell you point blank that birth wards, neo-natal care etc is not that fantastic in comparison to what's offered here in utah.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hey dont know how true this is but i was told by law pregnancy can not be considered a pre existing condition anymore, dont know how true that is but thats why my insurance company told me. And really if you want a good doc who will let you do things your way you should consider Dr. William Parker in PG. From what i have been told he is the most liberal in Utah county and lets you do what you want. And makes sure it happens your way, as much as possible, i mean with me he let me go 8 hours past when he first thought i should have a c-section, and only did one because my babys heart rate was WAY below what it needed to be. And AF is the way to go for hospitals!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Take the Medicaid.

    I'm going to have to stop reading your blog, because it's just much information for your old Dad to digest. But on that conception thing, what did you do, use Tim's room at his parents house where he grew up?? Weird.

    Love you. Dad

    ReplyDelete
  7. Like your Dad and I never did it anywhere in his parents house:)

    ReplyDelete
  8. Caitlin My Dear,

    I think you need to write a book or at least a column. I know lots of people here on the east coast would totally read.

    In other words, I love that you love homebirthing and breastfeeding and all things that are natural.

    Definitely at least get the advice of doctors in the hospitals or just talk to them about their process and how it could work for you.

    I'm also fairly certain that Pregnancy doesn't count as a pre-existing condition, and If I were you, I'd definitely see if you could push back the date of conception, a bit unethical, but aren't HMOs unethical in the first place?

    I know I know not an eye for an eye, but the things we'll do for our future!

    in conclusion,

    Hooray!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hmmm, you had four siblings born in the US and one in Europe. And Mom was normal and low-risk, right?

    ReplyDelete
  10. Yeah maybe I'll have to stop reading your blog too. I'm getting pretty scarred. Too much information for a single person like myself, and especially since you're married to my brother.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Haha I love your dad's comment. Aaron and I have totally done it in his childhood bedroom at his parents' house. During the daytime. I say it's kosher!

    I'm so so excited to hear about your birth experience now that you've got everything figured out!

    ReplyDelete
  12. MEdicaid is a great way to go, they pay for EVERYTHING, your care and the baby's. Also, it is highly recommended that for your first baby you should not go natural due to the many complications that come with having your first baby example I had toxemia/preclampsia which happens 1 out of 4 pregnancies. However, I would recommend Orem Community hospital, it is very small, and if you want to go natural you can. It's just that you are in a hospital when you do it. My best friend went natural there and she had a great experience. I think I might go natural for my second since my epidural wore off and I felt everything anyways, and even though I felt like I was going to die, it only lasted an hour. Also, with the home birth, a friend of our family had a home birth 3 months ago and the baby was a still born due to some complications from a home birth. Just a few things for you to think about

    ReplyDelete